VTI strategy verdict
Vanguard Total Stock Market (VTI) strategy verdict: The strategy underperforms buy-and-hold on VTI in its observed regime. Across all tickers, the pullback and risky-accumulation strategies beat holding in 89.8% of crash-regime backtests; that edge may not apply here.
Closed trades: 259 of 296 (87.5%) made money in default-settings backtests of the pullback strategy. A win rate counts closed trades only; a position that is still open and down is not in it.
Against buy-and-hold: 1.1% of 553 backtests beat holding VTI over the same dates (6 of 553). The median backtest's gap to holding was -8.7 points a year.
Median return across its backtests: 1.1% a year for the strategy, against 9.8% a year for buying and holding VTI over the same dates.
Average Sharpe ratio 0.41; average maximum drawdown -23.9%.
Risk level: informed gamble. Dominant regime: modest. History tested: about 25 years.
Backtests are research, not advice. Past results do not predict future returns, and most strategies we test do not beat holding.
What is VTI?
Vanguard's total US stock market ETF (VTI) is an index fund that aims to cover nearly the whole US stock market, from large companies down to small ones. It holds a broad collection of US-listed shares rather than only the biggest names.
Also searched for as: vti etf, total us stock market etf, vanguard total stock market etf, total stock market etf, vanguard vti.