Does buying the dip work on Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF?
Rarely. In 110 backtests over about 25 years of Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF (VTI) prices, buying the dip beat simply holding the shares in 6. On average it trailed holding by 1.6 percentage points a year.
Most trades made money, and it still trailed holding
The rule's trades usually worked. Of 296 closed trades at default settings, 259 (87.5%) made money. That is the figure most dip-buying claims quote, and it answers a different question. A win rate counts trades that closed in profit. It says nothing about the time spent in cash waiting for the next fall.
The falls were still deep
Buying after a fall did not avoid the big falls. The average backtest still had a worst fall of 37.3% from a peak.
Where buying the dip has held up
Across every ticker StrategyLens tests, the two dip-buying rules beat holding in 89.8% of 14,775 backtests run through crash periods.
How this was tested
"Buying the dip" here is the pullback rule: buy after a fall, sell on recovery or at a stop. The trade figures use its default settings. All figures assume no trading costs, are before tax and carry survivorship bias. They are simulated past results, not a forecast or a recommendation. Figures from the VTI card dated 29 October 2026; the full verdict is on the VTI page and the method on the methodology page.