SPY strategy verdict

SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY) strategy verdict: The strategy underperforms buy-and-hold on SPY in its observed regime. Across all tickers, the pullback and risky-accumulation strategies beat holding in 89.8% of crash-regime backtests; that edge may not apply here.

Closed trades: 344 of 392 (87.8%) made money in default-settings backtests of the pullback strategy. A win rate counts closed trades only; a position that is still open and down is not in it.

Against buy-and-hold: 0.5% of 553 backtests beat holding SPY over the same dates (3 of 553). The median backtest's gap to holding was -9.5 points a year.

Median return across its backtests: 1.3% a year for the strategy, against 10.8% a year for buying and holding SPY over the same dates.

Average Sharpe ratio 0.44; average maximum drawdown -28.7%.

Risk level: informed gamble. Dominant regime: modest. History tested: about 34 years.

Backtests are research, not advice. Past results do not predict future returns, and most strategies we test do not beat holding.

What is SPY (SPDR S&P 500 ETF)?

SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY) is an index fund from State Street's SPDR range that follows the S&P 500, an index of large US companies. It was the first ETF listed in the US and is set up as a unit investment trust.

Also searched for as: spy etf, s&p 500 etf, spdr s&p 500, spdr s&p 500 etf trust, spy s&p 500.