Why most strategies underperform buying and holding
Buying and holding means buying an investment once and keeping it through rises and falls. It sounds too simple to beat, and in our tests it usually is not beaten. This note explains why, using our own published results.
What our published results show
Across the 38 published tickers, 2,565 of 21,014 backtests beat buying and holding the same ticker over the same dates, which is 12.2%. On 37 of the 38 tickers, fewer than half of the backtests beat holding, and on 10 of them none did. The median ticker's share of backtests beating holding is 6.8%.
At the same time, the median ticker's headline strategy closed 81.6% of its trades at a profit. Most trades made money, and most strategies still trailed holding.
Figures are from the 38 StrategyLens published ticker cards, updated 29 October 2026. They are hypothetical backtests with no trading costs, before tax, and they will change as the cards are refreshed.
Reason 1: time out of the market
Most timing rules spend part of their time in cash, waiting for a signal. Stock markets have tended to rise over long periods, and some of the largest rises come in short bursts, often soon after falls. A rule that is in cash during a few of those days can fall a long way behind.
Reason 2: selling winners too early
Many rules take profits after a rebound. That produces a high win rate, but it caps the gains on the trades that would have kept running. Holding lets the largest winners run without limit.
Reason 3: costs and tax
Every trade has costs in real life: commission, spreads, foreign-exchange charges, and tax on gains outside an ISA. Holding pays them once. Our headline figures leave costs out, so real results for active strategies would trail holding by more than our figures show.
Reason 4: strong rises are hard to beat
Our tested periods include long rises for many of the published tickers. Holding a stock that grew strongly is a very high bar. On NVDA, holding grew at 36.4% a year over the tested dates against 8.3% for the median strategy backtest. On SPY, the figures are 10.8% and 1.3%.
Where strategies did better
The exceptions are informative. Strategies beat holding much more often in windows where holding did badly. In crash windows across the platform, 89.8% of backtests beat holding; in bull windows, 13.5% did. Avoiding falls is what timing rules do best, and the price is missing rises.
The ticker where most backtests beat holding, COIN at 95.5%, is a short history (about 6 years) dominated by large swings, which is exactly the setting in which stepping aside helps. A short, unusual history is also the setting in which a result is least likely to repeat.
What this does and does not mean
It does not mean no strategy can ever beat holding, or that holding is right for everyone. Some people value a smaller worst fall more than a higher return, and a strategy that trails holding may still suit them. It does mean that a claim to beat holding needs strong evidence, tested against the same dates, with costs, across many tickers and settings.
The hidden cost of being right
A timing rule that sells after a rebound and waits for the next dip is often right: the price does dip again. But if the price rises further before it dips, the rule buys back higher than it sold, or never buys back at all. Each of those misses is small on its own. Over years, they add up to a large gap.
This is why the share of profitable trades and the comparison with holding tell such different stories on our pages. A strategy can be right most of the time and still give up more on the times it was wrong, or out of the market, than it gained on the times it was right.
What to look for in a strategy that claims to beat holding
Was holding the same investment over the same dates shown on the same page? How much of the time was the strategy in cash? How many settings and tickers were tested, and how many beat holding? Did the result hold up on years not used to choose the settings? Were costs included? A claim that cannot answer these is not yet evidence.
There is also a behavioural point. Holding is simple to describe, but many people find it hard to do through a deep fall, and sell near the bottom. A strategy that trails holding on paper may still beat what a particular person would actually have done. That is a question about the person, not the strategy, and no backtest can answer it.
This is research, not financial advice. Past results, real or simulated, do not tell you what will happen next.
Do most trading strategies beat buy and hold?
Not in our tests. Across 38 published tickers, 12.2% of backtests beat holding the same ticker over the same dates, before costs.
Why do strategies with high win rates still lose to holding?
They often sell winners early and spend time in cash while prices rise, so they win often but by less than holding gains.
When do strategies beat holding?
Most often in falling markets, where holding takes the whole fall. In crash windows across our platform, 89.8% of backtests beat holding.