How to read a backtest equity curve
An equity curve is a chart of how much money a strategy would have had over time, starting from a fixed amount. It is the most common picture of a backtest, and it carries more information than a single return figure if you know what to look for.
This note explains how to read one. It uses no figures; the shapes it describes apply to any backtest.
Put holding on the same chart
An equity curve on its own nearly always rises over a long period, because markets have tended to rise. The question is whether it rose faster or more smoothly than simply holding the same investment. A curve without a buy-and-hold line beside it cannot answer that.
Check the scale
On a normal (linear) scale, growth late in a long test dominates the picture, and early periods look flat. On a logarithmic scale, equal percentage changes take up equal heights, which makes long periods easier to compare. Many charts do not say which they use, and the same data can look very different on each.
Look at the falls, not just the end point
The dips in the curve are drawdowns. How deep were they, how long did they last, and how long did recovery take? A curve that ends high after a 60% fall in the middle would have been very hard to follow in real life. The drawdown table or chart beside the curve, if there is one, shows these precisely.
Look for flat stretches
Long flat sections usually mean the strategy was in cash. If the buy-and-hold line rose during those stretches, the strategy missed that rise. Flat periods are where many timing rules fall behind.
Check where it starts and ends
A test that starts just after a market low and ends at a high flatters almost any strategy that holds stocks. A test that ends during a fall can understate it. Look at the start and end dates and what markets were doing then.
Shapes that should make you careful
A perfectly smooth, straight line. Real strategies have bad periods; a curve with none may be overfitted or may hide something, such as a strategy that earns small regular gains with a rare large loss not yet in the data.
Most of the gain in one short burst. If removing a single month or year would wipe out the advantage, the result depends on that event repeating.
A curve that improves sharply after a change in rules. If the rules were adjusted after seeing the early results, the later part is in-sample.
No costs mentioned. Frequent trading with costs left out can turn a falling real-life curve into a rising backtest one.
What the curve does not show
How many variations were tried before this one was chosen. Whether the result held up on years not used to choose the settings. What happened on other tickers. Those need separate figures, which is why our ticker pages show how often strategies beat holding across all their tested settings rather than a single best curve.
Equity curves on StrategyLens
Our ticker pages show figures summarised from every backtest of a ticker, compared with holding the same ticker over the same dates, rather than one chosen curve.
Comparing two curves fairly
Start both from the same amount on the same date and end them on the same date. Use the same scale. If one curve includes costs and the other does not, say so on the chart. And show the drawdowns of both underneath, so the reader can see what each path felt like, not only where it ended.
If a chart shows the strategy and holding, check which line is which, and whether holding includes dividends. A strategy line that includes dividends compared with a holding line that does not, or the other way round, can change the picture by a few percentage points a year over long periods.
Underwater charts
An underwater chart plots how far below its previous peak the curve was at each point. It sits at zero when the curve is at a new high and dips below zero during each drawdown. It makes the length and depth of bad periods much easier to see than the equity curve itself, and it is the clearest way to compare the pain of two strategies over the same dates.
Finally, remember that an equity curve is one path through history. A different start date, a slightly different setting or a different ticker would draw a different line. The curve is a picture of one test, not a promise of a shape to come, and the honest way to read it is alongside the figures that show how many other tests looked different.
This is research, not financial advice. Past results, real or simulated, do not tell you what will happen next.
What is an equity curve?
A chart of how much money a strategy would have had over time from a fixed starting amount.
Should an equity curve be on a log scale?
For long periods, a logarithmic scale makes equal percentage changes look equal, which makes early and late periods easier to compare.
What makes an equity curve suspicious?
A perfectly smooth line, most of the gain in one short burst, no buy-and-hold comparison, or no mention of costs.